Money basics

Moving closer to work: a break-even question

Shifting home to shorten the commute may save travel money but cost more in rent and moving. A simple break-even calculation tells you whether it pays.

Editorial illustration for Moving closer to work: a break-even question

A tempting solution

When the daily commute becomes a drain on time and money, the obvious remedy is to live closer to the workplace. Sometimes this works. Often the move brings a higher rent, a smaller home or a more expensive neighbourhood, and the savings in travel are cancelled out. The only way to know is to put the numbers on one page.

Total the current situation

Gather three months of records and find the average monthly figures for rent, utilities and commute. The commute includes all travel to work: fares, fuel, parking, feeder legs and the occasional cab. Add them to get the current monthly cost of housing plus getting to work.

Estimate the alternative

For the new place, find the likely rent, utilities and deposit, and estimate the commute from the same sources. Include moving costs, which are one-time but not small: transport of belongings, brokerage if any, deposits, setup of utilities and furnishings. Spread the one-time costs over the time you expect to stay.

In this invented example, the move costs 800 more per month in money, but saves a lot of time. Whether that is worthwhile is a personal judgement.

Count the time

  • Daily hours saved, multiplied by working days
  • What those hours would allow: sleep, family time, study
  • Effects on children’s schools and other household routines
  • Changes in the quality of the neighbourhood and its amenities

These considerations may not be reducible to a price, but writing them down next to the figures makes the decision more honest.

The break-even view

If the new arrangement costs more in money but saves time, the question is whether the saved time is worth the extra cost. If it costs less in money and saves time, the answer is simple. If it costs more and saves little time, it may not be worth moving.

For a one-off cost like the move, divide the total by the monthly saving to see how many months it takes to recover. If the saving is 1,000 a month and moving costs 24,000, recovery takes two years, which is a long wait if the stay is likely to be shorter.

Remember the exit costs

Breaking a lease early, forfeiting a deposit or paying notice rent can be large. Check the terms of your current tenancy before assuming a clean transition, and record these costs among the one-time items.

A pilot before the commitment

If possible, test the proposed area before moving. Spend a few days travelling from the potential neighbourhood to work at the actual hours, noting costs and times. Visit in the evening to see how the area feels. Evidence from a pilot is more reliable than assumptions drawn from a map.

Also ask existing residents about hidden recurring costs: maintenance charges, parking, water supply arrangements and typical price levels in local shops. These details rarely appear in a rent figure but affect the monthly total.

Finally, think about what you would do if the job changed. A move made for the sake of a particular workplace carries a risk if the workplace moves, the role changes or you leave. A location with good connections to several parts of the city is a safer choice than one tied to a single employer.

Check, too, whether any part of the move can be shared. A flatmate, a sublet of the spare room or an arrangement with a relative nearby can bring the housing line down and tilt the break-even in favour of moving.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports