Budgeting

Name categories after decisions, not shops

Categories built around the choices you actually make stay useful when stores, apps and brands change, and they produce reports you can act on.

Editorial illustration for Name categories after decisions, not shops

A naming problem that looks like a filing problem

When people set up categories, the instinct is to file by where the money went: a category for each supermarket, one for each delivery app, one for a favourite cafe. That seems natural because bank statements list merchants. But merchants come and go, and a report organised by shop tells you where you paid, not what you decided.

A decision-based category asks a different question: what choice was I making when I spent this? That framing turns reports into tools for adjustment.

Shops describe the past, decisions describe the future

Imagine two reports. The first lists spending at five named stores. The second lists “Groceries to cook at home”, “Ready meals”, and “Eating out”. If you wished to spend less on food, which would help you more? The second one points at three behaviours you could change. The first merely tells you which shops you visit.

Moreover, when one of those stores closes or a new app arrives, the decision-based categories stay valid. Only the merchant mapping changes.

Finding the decision behind a purchase

To rename a category, ask what the alternative would have been. If you bought a coffee out, the alternative was making one at home or skipping it. That suggests a category such as “Drinks out”. If you paid for a taxi, the alternative was a bus or a lift. That suggests “Convenience transport”.

This kind of naming forces a small moment of reflection. Over time it also helps you see which decisions are worth their price.

Some examples side by side

Merchant-style labelDecision-style label
Large hypermarketWeekly household stock-up
Delivery appMeals brought to the door
Ride-hailingDoor-to-door transport
Online marketplacePlanned purchases / impulse purchases
PharmacyHealth supplies

The right-hand column might feel wordier, and you are free to shorten the labels. The principle is that each name tells you why the money moved, not just who received it.

Do not abandon the merchant data

Decision labels do not replace merchant names; they sit above them. The merchant remains visible in the transaction detail and can be searched. Think of the category as a heading and the merchant as an item under it.

Where an app supports merchant rules, you can map several merchants to one decision category. A weekly stock-up might include three different stores, all of which route to the same label.

A caution about over-engineering

It is possible to push this too far. If every purchase demands a philosophical judgement, the system becomes burdensome. Use decision-based names where the choice is real and varied, such as food, transport and shopping. For fixed obligations such as rent or insurance, a plain label is fine, since there is no decision to track each month.

Likewise, do not feel obliged to rename everything at once. Start with your three largest categories and see whether the new names change how you read your monthly report. If you share the tracker with a partner, agree the new names together, since a label only works if both of you would put the same purchase under it.

Living with the change

Renaming categories affects your history. If your tracker lets you rename in place, the old transactions simply adopt the new label, which is usually what you want. If the old and new meanings differ significantly, consider adding a note on the date you changed, so you remember not to compare figures across the break without care.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports