Saving money

Overlapping policies: finding them on your own list

Several small covers can overlap without anyone noticing. A single list of everything you pay for shows where the duplication is.

Editorial illustration for Overlapping policies: finding them on your own list

How overlap happens

Insurance accumulates over time. An employer provides group cover. A bank adds a card-linked cover. A loan comes with a bundled policy. A parent buys an individual plan. A travel policy lingers on a card. Add a family floater, a personal accident plan and a few add-ons, and the household is paying for protection from half a dozen sources, none of which has been compared with the others.

Overlap is not always wasteful. Different policies may complement each other. But without a list, nobody can say which is which, and the household may be paying twice for the same benefit or, worse, assuming a benefit that does not exist.

Create the master list

Search your transactions for insurance-related merchants over the past year, and check bank statements for debits that mention premiums. Look in email for policy documents and renewal notices. Ask family members what they hold. For each policy, write the insurer, type, persons covered, sum insured, premium and renewal date.

PolicyTypeCoversPremium per yearRenews
Policy oneHealth floaterFamily22,000Month 4
Policy twoGroup healthEmployee and spousePaid by employerEmployment dependent
Policy threePersonal accidentAdult3,000Month 9
Policy fourCard-linked coverCardholderIncludedWith card

Look for overlaps in benefits

Group the list by benefit: hospitalisation, accident, critical illness, daily cash, travel. For each, ask which policies provide it and whether they pay separately or share. Several health policies may allow claims across them, but rules about how claims are coordinated vary and must be checked with the insurers.

Separate real redundancy from useful layers

A group policy plus a personal policy is a layer, valuable if the group cover ends with the job. Two small policies with the same narrow benefit may be genuine duplication. Cancelling something that overlaps can free money, but cancelling something that is your only protection can leave a hole. Make decisions one policy at a time, with the documents in hand.

Count the cost

Add the premiums to see the total spent on protection. Compare it with income and with the value you place on each cover. If a policy no longer serves a purpose, consider ending it at renewal, after confirming there will be no unwelcome consequences such as loss of accumulated benefits.

Keep the list alive

Review the list once a year, ideally at the same time as the budget review. Add new policies, remove ended ones, update premiums. Share a copy with a trusted family member. In an emergency, a single page that tells them what cover exists is invaluable.

Check how claims are coordinated

If you hold more than one policy that can pay for hospitalisation, ask each insurer how claims are handled when another policy also applies. Rules about coordination, the order in which policies pay and what documents are needed from the first insurer differ. Write the answers in your notes. This is especially important if you hold both an employer’s policy and a personal one.

Do not assume that two policies will pay the same bill twice. The usual principle is that you are reimbursed for actual expenses, not more, but the practical details are specific to each case.

Plan the clean-up with care

Before cancelling anything, confirm what you would lose: accumulated bonus, waiting periods served or a feature unavailable in newer plans. Sometimes the oldest policy is the most valuable precisely because of its accumulated benefits. Make a list of pros and cons for each candidate for cancellation and sleep on it.

If you decide to stop a policy, wait for the renewal date, give notice in writing where required, and keep the confirmation. Update your master list and the calendar the same day.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports