Money basics

Repair or replace: a cost-per-year test for old appliances

When an old appliance breaks again, the choice between another repair and a new purchase is easier with one simple calculation.

Editorial illustration for Repair or replace: a cost-per-year test for old appliances

The familiar dilemma

The washing machine stops. The repair quote is 40 per cent of the price of a new one. The technician says it might last another year, or maybe three. Paying for repair feels like throwing good money after bad, and buying new feels extravagant. A simple cost-per-year comparison cuts through the uncertainty.

The cost-per-year idea

For each option, estimate the total cost and the years of service it is expected to deliver, then divide. The option with the lower cost per year of use is, on the money alone, the better choice.

For repair, the cost is the repair bill, and the years are the extra life you expect. For replacement, the cost is the price of the new appliance, less any exchange value, and the years are its expected life.

An illustrative comparison

OptionCostExpected yearsCost per year
Repair the old machine4,00022,000
Replace with new22,000102,200

Here the repair is slightly cheaper per year, though close. Add the cost of running the two machines, since a new one may use less power and water, and the balance might tip. The numbers are examples. Use quotes and realistic estimates.

Factors the arithmetic leaves out

  • Reliability: an old machine may break again soon
  • Efficiency: newer models may cost less to run
  • Features: a new model may do things you actually need
  • Disruption: a breakdown at an awkward time costs more than money
  • Safety: old electrical appliances can become hazardous

Weigh these alongside the numbers. When money is very tight, repair may be the only option, and that is a legitimate choice.

Using your own records

Your repair category tells you how often this appliance has needed fixing and how much it has cost already. If this is its third repair in two years, the pattern argues for replacement. If it is its first in eight, a repair looks more sensible.

Making the purchase wisely

If you replace, collect quotes, check warranty terms and ask about installation and disposal of the old unit. Record the purchase with the warranty details, and set a reminder for when the warranty ends. Spreading the cost over the expected life is a useful way to understand what you are paying.

Learning from the choice

A year later, check whether the decision worked as expected. Did the repaired appliance last? Did the new one meet expectations? Your own record of such decisions becomes a guide for the next one, and it takes the guesswork out of a recurring question.

Estimating expected years honestly

Expected life is a guess, and it helps to be modest. Ask the technician how long the repaired appliance is likely to last, and treat the answer with some caution. For new appliances, the warranty period and your experience with similar items are better guides than marketing claims.

Disposal and exchange

Old appliances may have an exchange value or a disposal cost. Ask the seller of the new unit what they offer, and record the figure in your comparison. A responsible disposal, through a collection scheme or a recycler, is part of the replacement and deserves a place in the cost.

Setting a personal rule

Many households settle on a rule of thumb, such as replacing when a repair costs more than half the price of a new one. A rule is only a starting point, but it speeds up decisions in the stressful moment after a breakdown. Choose yours in advance, and write it in your home notes.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports