Saving money

Saving from one repeated expense instead of everything at once

Cutting broadly rarely lasts. Choosing a single, regular expense to reduce, and moving the difference to savings, is easier to sustain.

Editorial illustration for Saving from one repeated expense instead of everything at once

The trouble with across-the-board cuts

Resolving to spend less on everything is vague and tiring. It demands constant vigilance and leads to a feeling of deprivation. Most such resolutions fail within a few weeks, not from lack of will but from the sheer number of decisions involved.

This is also why many budgets with thirty categories fail. Each category is another decision, and the effort of watching them all exceeds the benefit.

Targeting one repeated expense is more manageable. You make one decision, and the saving follows without further effort.

Write the rule down in a single sentence, such as “Delivery only on Fridays”, and place it where you will see it. Clear, short rules are easier to follow than good intentions.

Finding the candidate

Look at your transactions for the last three months and find the payee or category that appears most often. Candidates might include food delivery, a daily beverage, rides, small online orders or a regular snack stop. Sort by frequency, not just amount, since the repeated small ones are the sneaky ones.

Do not forget that the repeated expense may be shared. If the whole household orders in, a small adjustment by everyone makes a bigger difference than a heroic effort by one person.

Pick one whose reduction would not seriously reduce your quality of life.

Doing the arithmetic

Count how many times it occurred per month and the average amount. Multiply to get the monthly total. Then decide what share to reduce.

It is worth counting honestly, including the times it is bought by someone else on your account or card. Shared accounts and family orders can hide the true total of a repeated expense.

ExpenseTimes a monthAverageMonthly total
Delivery orders123804,560
Beverages out20901,800
Short rides151201,800

If delivery is the target, cutting it by a third saves about 1,500 a month, or 18,000 a year.

Choosing the form of the cut

There are several ways to reduce.

  1. Do it less often, such as moving from twelve orders to eight.
  2. Do it more cheaply, such as ordering from a cheaper place or sharing.
  3. Replace it, such as cooking at home on a few of the days.
  4. Stop it entirely, if it brings little value.

Choose the form that matches your temperament. Some people prefer a clear rule, others a gentle reduction.

Moving the money

The key is to move the saved amount at once. If you skip an order, transfer its cost to a savings pot. This turns the reduction into visible savings. If you rely on the money simply staying in your account, it will drift into something else.

A simple way is a weekly transfer equal to the average weekly saving from the target expense.

Tracking the progress

Check after a month. Did the count fall? Was the amount moved? If so, note the saving and its running total. If the expense returned, ask why and adjust your approach. Small experiments teach more than perfect plans.

Avoiding substitution

Beware of replacing the cut with another expense, such as cutting food delivery but buying more snacks. Watch the neighbouring categories in your reports to see if costs have simply moved.

Also notice how you feel. If the change leaves you irritable or resentful, it may be too harsh, and a milder version will last longer than a strict one that breaks.

Adding a second target later

Once the first change has become routine, perhaps after two or three months, choose another. Gradual progress adds up, and each success makes the next easier.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports