Saving money

Smart plugs, timers and gadgets: do they pay for themselves?

Gadgets sold as energy savers have a price and often a running cost of their own. A payback calculation separates the useful ones from the clutter.

Editorial illustration for Smart plugs, timers and gadgets: do they pay for themselves?

The promise of the gadget

Smart plugs, timers, sensors and similar devices are marketed with the idea of saving power or money. Some do. Others save almost nothing and add to the clutter or even use more electricity than they save. The way to tell is a simple payback calculation based on your own use.

What to find out

Before buying anything, gather the following.

  1. The price of the device, including any accessories
  2. The power it draws itself, often listed in the specifications
  3. The appliance it will control, its power draw and its hours of use
  4. How much of that use is wasted: for example, a heater left on after it is needed
  5. Your electricity rate

Without these numbers, any claim of savings is a guess.

An illustrative calculation

Suppose a timer costs 600 and controls a water heater that wastes 30 minutes a day by being left on. If the heater draws 2,000 watts, that is one unit of electricity wasted per day. At a rate of 7 per unit, the waste is about 2,550 per year. The timer repays in under three months. Now suppose the same timer controls a lamp that wastes 30 minutes a day at 10 watts. The waste is a few units a year and the timer never repays.

DeviceCostYearly savingPayback
Timer on water heater6002,550Under 3 months
Timer on a lamp60012Never

The numbers are examples.

Include running costs

Some devices connect to apps, use standby power or require subscriptions. Add these to the cost. A device that draws power constantly to save power later has to save more than it uses. Check the specifications and be sceptical of claims without numbers.

Behaviour is cheaper

Often, a habit achieves what a gadget promises. Switching off a heater when you leave the bathroom costs nothing. The gadget is useful only if the habit is hard to keep. Ask honestly whether you would remember without it.

Keep what works, return the rest

If a device does not help, return or sell it within the return period. Record the purchase and the outcome, so you can see whether your gadget buying pays off or not. A modest, well-chosen device on a heavy load can be a very good value. A drawer full of unused gadgets is not.

Measure the effect

After installing a device, compare bills for similar months. A drop in units that fits your calculation is evidence that it works. If nothing changes, the savings were smaller than expected. A few months of tracking turns opinion into knowledge.

Matching the device to the load

Gadgets help most with large loads that are easy to forget: heaters, geysers, cooling units and pumps. For small loads, the saving is usually tiny. Spend your attention on the big appliances first, using the list of heavy users from your electricity review.

Checking reviews and servicing

Cheap devices may fail early or lack support. Check the warranty and the seller's return terms. A device that stops working after a few months wastes its cost, so keep the bill and the warranty card in your folder.

Privacy and security

Connected devices can collect data and may need regular updates. Read what the device records and who can see it, change default passwords and keep the software current. A device that saves a few units but weakens the security of your home network is not a bargain.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports