Security

Talking to older relatives about scams without shaming them

Warnings land better when they respect independence. Ways to start the conversation and keep the door open.

Editorial illustration for Talking to older relatives about scams without shaming them

Why the tone matters

When we worry about an older relative, the urge is to warn loudly and repeat the warnings. Yet people who feel patronised often stop listening or stop telling you things. The aim is the opposite: a relative who tells you when something odd happens, early, because they trust that you will help and not scold.

How you speak matters as much as what you say.

Start with a story, not an instruction

Begin with something you heard or read, not with their behaviour. Say that a neighbour or a colleague received a strange call, and describe how the trick worked. Ask what they would have done. People engage with a puzzle more readily than with a lecture.

Avoid phrases like “you must” and “you always”. Use “I was reading about” and “have you ever had a call like this?”.

Ask and listen

Ask whether they have received odd messages or calls. Many have, and will tell you if the question feels safe. Listen to the whole account before offering advice. If they did respond to something, thank them for telling you and move to the next step calmly.

Offer a few simple rules

Pick two or three, not twenty:

  1. Hang up on any caller who asks for money, a PIN or a code.
  2. Check with a family member before acting on a message about money.
  3. Do not click links in messages; use the bank’s app or number from the card.

Write them in large print and leave them near the phone. Repeat them at gentle intervals.

Respect their control

Many older people value control over their own money. Instead of taking over, offer tools they can choose: lower limits, alerts to a family member, a weekly review together. Ask permission before setting anything up. Explain that these measures protect against criminals, not against them.

Create an easy path to ask

Agree on a quick way to reach you, and promise a calm response. Tell them that you would much rather take ten calls that turn out to be nothing than miss one that is real. Avoid reacting with irritation, even when you are busy; the next call may depend on it.

If something has happened

Stay calm. Ask for the facts, help them contact the bank, and write the timeline together. Reassure them that this happens to many people and is not a sign of foolishness. Avoid the question “how could you?”, which closes conversations. Offer support with the practical tasks and with the feelings.

Keep it going

Make scam talk a normal subject, as ordinary as the weather. Mention new tricks when you hear of them. Include them in the family code word and call-back habits. A relative who takes part in the plan is much safer than one who is simply told what to do.

Your own habits

Finally, practise what you say. Show how you check a message, how you decline a call. Older relatives often learn best by watching the people they trust.

Small practical gestures

Offer to sit with them while they set up alerts, so the settings are theirs. Print the three rules in a large font. Add family numbers and the bank’s card-blocking number to a sheet near the phone. Bring up the subject over a meal or a walk, not in the middle of a crisis. Small, friendly gestures show respect and build the habit of talking, which is the strongest protection of all.

When they push back

Some relatives resist, saying they are careful enough. Do not argue. Ask them to teach you how they check a message, and listen. Often their method is partly sound, and you can build on it. If they decline any help, keep the conversation open and revisit it after the next news story about a scam. Patience tends to work better than pressure.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports