A buyer who is too generous
You list an item for sale and a buyer replies within minutes. They accept the price without bargaining. They then say a payment has been sent, but a mistake was made and it was too high, and they ask you to return the extra. Or a payment screen is shown as proof, and a courier is on the way.
It all moves quickly. The urgency, the lack of haggling and the proof offered as an image should each make you slower.
How the trick works
The proof of payment is the weak point. A screenshot can be made or edited by anyone, and a pending payment can be shown on a screen long before it settles, or never arrive. If you send back the “extra”, you send real money out against a payment that does not exist or is later reversed.
Sometimes the buyer asks you to approve something to “receive” the money. This is the collect-request trick in another costume.
The one check that settles it
Do not rely on messages, screenshots or the buyer’s word. Look at your own account. Open your bank or payment app directly and see whether the exact amount has settled as a credit. Not pending, not “processing”: settled, with a reference you can match to the buyer.
If it has not appeared, nothing is owed and nothing should be sent. If it has appeared and is larger than agreed, the safest course is to wait until the payment is final and then discuss how to refund through the same route it came, rather than to a new account the buyer provides.
Safer ways to sell
- Meet in person for modest items and accept payment you can see arrive before handing over the goods.
- Use the platform’s own payment and protection features when available, and keep conversation on the platform.
- Be cautious when a buyer asks for a different delivery address from the one they gave, or wants you to ship before payment is final.
- Never release an item based only on a screenshot.
None of these rules insults an honest buyer. An honest buyer is happy to wait ten minutes for a payment to show.
Writing it into your records
When you sell something, note it in your records as income or as a refund against the original purchase, with the date, the buyer’s reference and the route used. Selling a used item is not always a taxable event, and the rules vary, so check official sources if you sell regularly. For safety, though, a record helps you reconcile what was promised with what arrived.
If a sale falls through because you spotted the trick, make a short note. A repeated pattern in your messages tells you something about where you advertise.
If you already returned money
Gather the chat history, the screenshots and the details of the transfer you made. Contact your bank right away, describe the sequence, and ask what can be done. Report the buyer’s profile to the platform. Keep a note of the time you noticed the problem, as that is the first thing any investigator will ask.
A calmer way to feel about it
Being fooled by a polished buyer does not mean you were careless; it means the script was good. A rule that you never refund until the credit has settled is a protection that does not depend on spotting the con each time. It is the kind of rule you can set once and follow without agonising.
When the buyer is a business
Trade buyers, resellers and agents sometimes pay by methods that take longer to clear, and some are perfectly honest. The same test still applies. Ask what the settlement time is, wait for it, and see the credit in your own account before anything leaves your hands. A genuine business will have a procedure and will not mind waiting. If a buyer treats your caution as an insult, treat that as information, and let the sale go.
Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.
Explore your reports


