Debt

Using tags to show why you borrowed

Categories describe what money was spent on. A simple tag attached to each loan or instalment can also record why you took on the debt, helping you judge it later.

Editorial illustration for Using tags to show why you borrowed

What categories cannot say

A repayment sits in the loan category, whatever it was originally for. A year later, the reason for the borrowing can be forgotten, or remembered differently by two people in the household. Was it a medical bill, an appliance, a business tool, a wedding, or a way of covering a shortfall? The answer affects how you feel about the debt and how you plan to deal with it.

A small set of purpose tags

  • Need: something essential that could not be postponed
  • Investment: something expected to earn or save money
  • Comfort: a purchase that improves life but could wait
  • Bridge: borrowing to cover a gap in cash flow
  • Rollover: borrowing to repay other borrowing

Five tags are enough. More than that makes the habit tiresome. You can rename them to suit your own situation.

Tagging at the moment of borrowing

When the loan starts, tag the disbursal and the instalment bill. Add the purpose tag and perhaps a short note about the decision. If the whole household took part in the choice, mention who. The extra thirty seconds today can save an hour of reconstruction later.

Reading the tags once a year

TagShare of this year’s interestWhat it suggests
Need40 percentUnavoidable costs; plan an emergency fund
Investment25 percentCheck whether the return arrived
Comfort20 percentQuestion how much of this was wise
Bridge10 percentLook at the monthly gap
Rollover5 percentA warning sign worth attention

The percentages are made up for the sake of illustration. What matters is the habit of looking. A large share in Bridge or Rollover suggests the problem lies in monthly cash flow, not in any one purchase.

What to do with the findings

If Need dominates, the best protection is a stronger emergency fund so that the next surprise does not become a loan. If Comfort dominates, it may be worth creating a savings goal for such purchases, and paying in cash next time. If Rollover appears at all, take it seriously: borrowing to repay borrowing is a sign to talk to a qualified adviser.

A kind way to review

The tags are not a verdict. Everyone has borrowed for reasons that seemed right at the time. The purpose of the exercise is to learn which kinds of borrowing worked well for you and which did not. Review in a relaxed mood, with a cup of tea, and write down one lesson.

Share the lesson with anyone who shares your money. A household that agrees on the rules of borrowing, such as ‘no comfort purchases on loans’, spends less energy arguing about each case.

Tagging other kinds of money

The same idea works beyond loans. A tag on a large one-off purchase, such as ‘planned’ or ‘unplanned’, can help you judge how many of your big costs were surprises. Over time you may find that many ‘emergencies’ were predictable, which suggests a sinking fund rather than a loan.

Keep tags few and plain. If you cannot remember the meaning of a tag, it is too clever. The best tags are ones that anyone in the household could apply without explanation.

Reviewing with a partner

If two people share the budget, each can tag their own borrowing decisions and then compare notes. It often turns out that the two see the same debt differently: one remembers it as a need, the other as a comfort. Talking it through, without blame, leads to clearer rules for next time.

A short household rule, written on one line, makes a good outcome. For instance, ‘any loan over one month’s income needs a week’s wait and a written reason.’ The tags give you the evidence to decide whether such a rule would have helped.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports