Business

Winning customers versus keeping them: where the money goes

Spending to find a new customer usually costs more than serving an existing one. Sorting marketing money into the two buckets shows whether the balance is right.

Editorial illustration for Winning customers versus keeping them: where the money goes

Two kinds of effort

Every business spends on getting new customers: adverts, samples, discounts, events, cold outreach. It also spends on holding on to the ones it has: reminders, loyalty offers, good service, follow-up calls, small gifts. Often these are not separated, and the money is lumped under “marketing”.

When they are split, a pattern appears. Most businesses find that the cost of winning a new customer is several times the cost of keeping an old one.

Sort the spending

Go through the last quarter’s marketing and sales-related spending and place each item in one of two groups.

  • Winning: adverts, sample runs, introductory discounts, referral rewards, sponsorships, site visits for quotes
  • Keeping: reminder messages, loyalty credits, thank-you gifts, after-sales calls, repeat-order discounts

Some items, such as the website, serve both. Split them by a reasonable share or leave them in a separate “general” group.

Compare per customer

Divide each group’s spend by the number of customers it relates to. If winning cost 24,000 and brought 12 new customers, that is 2,000 each. If keeping cost 6,000 across 60 returning customers, that is 100 each.

GroupSpendCustomersCost per customer
------------
Winning24,000122,000
Keeping6,00060100

The gap is large, and it is typical. A customer kept is far cheaper than a customer found.

What the balance suggests

If nearly all the money goes into winning and almost none into keeping, customers may leave faster than they should. A modest rise in retention can be worth more than a big push in acquisition. Equally, a business that never looks for new customers will shrink as old ones drift away.

The balance depends on the trade. A shop selling items that customers rarely rebuy needs steady acquisition. A service with regular needs, such as cleaning or tutoring, rewards retention strongly.

Look at repeat rates

Count how many customers in a quarter bought more than once. If the number is low, ask why. Is the product one-off? Is service patchy? Is follow-up missing? Simple actions, such as a message after delivery, a reminder when a refill is due, or a call to ask how it went, often lift repeat business at little cost.

Tagging acquisition and retention spending

In SpendixAI, using two categories or tags, such as acquisition and retention, makes the split visible without extra work. Every quarter, compare the totals with the numbers of new and returning customers. If the ratio drifts, change the mix of spending, and check that the next quarter reflects the decision.

A simple quarterly question

At each quarter’s end, ask three things. Which customers bought for the first time, and how did they arrive? Which customers did not return, and when did they last buy? What did it cost, in money and time, to look after those who stayed? Writing a line against each question produces a short and surprisingly informative page.

Patterns appear quickly: a lapse after a certain number of months, a source of new customers that never returns, or a group of loyal buyers who have never been thanked. Each pattern suggests a modest action for the following quarter.

A short worked review

Suppose a quarter shows 12 new customers won at a combined cost of 24,000, and 60 returning customers served for 6,000. If the returning group spent 150,000 in total and the new group 30,000, then every unit spent on keeping customers sat beside 25 units of sales, while every unit spent on winning sat beside little more than 1. The comparison does not say to abandon acquisition. It says that a small shift toward follow-up may produce a larger return than another round of adverts, and the next quarter can test that.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports