Debt

Flat rate or reducing balance? The same loan, counted two ways

Two lenders can quote the same-looking rate and still charge very different amounts, depending on whether interest is counted on the original sum or on the shrinking balance.

Editorial illustration for Flat rate or reducing balance? The same loan, counted two ways

Same number, different meaning

A quoted interest figure means little until you know what it is applied to. On a flat basis, interest is calculated on the original amount for the whole term, however much you have already repaid. On a reducing-balance basis, interest is calculated only on what is still outstanding each period. A lower-looking flat figure can cost as much as, or more than, a higher-looking reducing one.

A worked comparison with round numbers

Suppose you borrow 120,000 units for twelve months, with a made-up yearly figure of 10 percent. On the flat method, interest is 10 percent of 120,000 for one year, which is 12,000. The total repayable is 132,000, or 11,000 a month.

On the reducing method, you pay interest only on the shrinking balance. Because you are repaying 10,000 units of principal each month in a simple version, the average balance across the year is about half the starting amount. Interest comes to roughly 6,500, not 12,000. The same quoted figure produced almost double the cost under the flat method.

MethodWhat interest is charged onRough interest for the yearMonthly payment
FlatOriginal 120,000 throughout12,00011,000
ReducingBalance left each monthAbout 6,500About 10,540

These numbers are only to show the gap. Real products add fees, rounding and different compounding, so use a lender’s own schedule for any actual decision.

Why flat quotes appear attractive

Flat pricing often appears in shop-counter finance or small-ticket purchases, where the headline is a small monthly figure. The borrower sees a tidy total and a short term and does not notice that the interest is calculated as though the full amount stayed outstanding to the last day.

How to compare offers fairly

  1. Ask the lender to state the total amount you will repay across the whole term.
  2. Divide the total by the loan amount to see the multiple you are paying back.
  3. Add any fees and charges that are not part of the instalment.
  4. Compare totals and monthly outflow, not only the quoted figure.

This works whatever the labelling. The total repayable, set against the amount you actually received in hand, is the one measure that cannot be dressed up.

Recording the comparison for later

Before signing, jot the offers in a note or on a planned bill in SpendixAI, with the monthly outflow and the total. When the loan starts, the instalment shows up in your transactions and you can check that the debits match what you were promised. If they do not, you will catch it in the first month, when it is easiest to question.

What to do when the lender’s document says something else

Documents use different phrases for the same thing: interest rate, yield, effective rate, annual percentage. If you cannot tell which method a quote uses, ask one plain question: if I repay on schedule, what is the total amount that leaves my account from first instalment to last? The answer is a single figure that can be compared with any other offer, whatever the method behind it.

It also helps to ask what happens if you repay early. Under flat pricing, early repayment sometimes saves less than a borrower expects, because the interest was fixed at the start. Under reducing pricing, early repayment cuts future interest directly.

A habit for the shop counter

Small-ticket finance at a shop counter is where flat pricing most often appears. Before signing, step aside for two minutes, open a note, and write down the instalment, the number of months and the total. Multiply, compare with the cash price, and decide with the pen in your hand rather than the salesperson’s patter.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports