Saving money

Petrol, diesel or CNG: a cost-per-kilometre test you can run yourself

Comparing fuel types by sticker price per litre can mislead. A cost-per-kilometre test using your own mileage gives a fairer view.

Editorial illustration for Petrol, diesel or CNG: a cost-per-kilometre test you can run yourself

Price per litre is the wrong comparison

Petrol, diesel and gas are sold in different units, and vehicles using them travel different distances on each unit. Comparing pump prices alone is like comparing the price of a kilo of rice with the price of a litre of milk. What matters is the cost of covering one kilometre.

The formula

Cost per kilometre equals the price of one unit of fuel divided by the kilometres you travel on that unit. If a vehicle runs 15 kilometres on a unit that costs 90, the fuel cost is 6 per kilometre. A second vehicle running 22 kilometres on a unit costing 80 comes to about 3.6. The cheaper pump price in that example is nearly irrelevant next to the difference in distance.

All figures here are illustrative. Use your own pump prices and your own measured distance per unit, which can be calculated from full-tank entries.

Using real figures, not claimed ones

Brochure mileage is produced under controlled conditions. Real use includes traffic, air-conditioning, hills, loads and driving style. For a fair test, take your own records: the fuel quantity and the distance between two consecutive full tanks. Repeat for three or four intervals and average them.

If a choice between fuel types is being considered for a future purchase, the same method applies to a vehicle owned by someone with similar driving conditions. Ask them for their real distance per unit and the pump price they pay, and put those numbers into the formula.

The part the formula cannot see

  • Purchase price: vehicles with different fuel systems often cost different amounts at purchase, and that gap has to be recovered through savings.
  • Maintenance: service schedules and parts differ between fuel types.
  • Refuelling convenience: how easily the fuel can be found on your usual routes.
  • Resale: how the market treats each type when you sell.
  • Rules: local regulations and restrictions can change, so check the official source before relying on them.

A break-even sketch

Suppose one option costs 100,000 units more to buy but saves 2.4 units on every kilometre. Divide 100,000 by 2.4 and the answer is roughly 41,700 kilometres. If the household drives 10,000 kilometres a year, that is more than four years before the extra purchase cost is recovered, ignoring other differences. If it drives 25,000 kilometres, the recovery takes under two years.

The table shows why distance is the deciding variable. A low-mileage household rarely benefits from paying more upfront for lower running costs.

Record the decision, then revisit it

If the calculation is part of a purchase decision, save the workings in a note attached to a goal or a budget line. A year after buying, compare actual fuel spend per kilometre with what the calculation predicted. The gap teaches you how much to trust such estimates next time.

Mixed driving changes the answer

Cost per kilometre is not one fixed figure for a vehicle. City driving, highway cruising and hill roads each produce a different result. A household that spends most of its time in dense traffic should use the city figure, even if the highway figure looks better on paper. Tag trips by type for a month or two, and the averages for each will emerge from your own records. The comparison between fuel types should then use the mix that matches your life, not the best case. A choice that wins in an ideal test can lose in the lanes you actually drive.

Finally, remember that any fuel comparison is a snapshot. Pump prices move, and so does your driving. Repeat the test once a year using fresh figures, and keep the earlier results in a note so that you can see whether the ranking between options has changed.

SPENDIXAI JOURNAL

Useful ideas start with a clearer picture of your own spending.

Explore your reports